Skip directly to content

Mixed methods for vaccine confidence in underserved communities

Vaccine hesitancy in underserved communities is rarely one fixed belief. It can reflect low confidence in vaccine safety, mistrust of institutions, language barriers, limited access, or competing daily priorities. Australian programmes need to distinguish these drivers without turning structural barriers into personal blame.

Mixed methods research combines numerical evidence about coverage and attitudes with detailed accounts from people affected by vaccination decisions. For teams in Melbourne, Sydney and regional Australia, the Lower New York State Public Health Training Center offers courses and resources that can be adapted for community-led immunisation planning.

Choose a mixed-methods design

Begin with the decision the study must support, then choose a design. Explanatory sequences begin with a survey and use interviews to explain unexpected patterns; exploratory sequences start with interviews and build a survey from the themes found. Convergent designs gather both types of evidence at once and compare them.

Design Sequence Best suited to Example
Explanatory sequential Survey first, then qualitative follow-up Explaining unexpected coverage or attitude patterns Test why a high-income area has lower uptake
Exploratory sequential Interviews or focus groups first, then a survey Developing questions when community perspectives are unclear Identify barriers to booking evening clinics
Convergent parallel Both strands at the same time Comparing numerical patterns with lived explanations Link coverage data with focus-group themes

Use an explanatory design when a local authority needs to understand a coverage gap, and an exploratory design when little is known about community perspectives. In regional and remote northern Queensland, distance, transport and limited staffing must remain visible in every design choice rather than being mistaken for vaccine refusal.

Ground the inquiry with communities

Create a paid community advisory group before drafting questions. In Melbourne, involve local health services and culturally diverse community organisations; in Sydney, include migrant and refugee settlement partners. Across Australia, commission Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander partners through their own governance structures, giving them authority over research priorities and data.

Agree on recruitment, compensation, locations, accessibility and feedback before collecting data. Offer interpreters, transport or childcare support, and use trusted local venues rather than expecting people to travel to a university. For structured planning that links activities, assumptions and outcomes, the Limes Romanus resource provides a useful reference.

Use qualitative methods to hear nuance

Qualitative methods reveal the reasoning hidden behind a hesitant response. Focus groups can compare messages across participants, while individual interviews suit people who prefer not to speak in a group. A trained facilitator should ask open questions, explore trusted information sources, and avoid treating every concern as misinformation or an opportunity for persuasion.

Record discussions with consent, protect anonymity in group settings, and let community partners review de-identified themes. Analyse patterns around access, trust, cultural expectations and previous experiences with health services. A person who cannot find a clinic may describe convenience and access, not a lack of confidence, so the coding frame must keep those explanations distinct.

Use quantitative methods to map patterns

The quantitative strand should establish scale without erasing variation. Use current population denominators, service-level coverage data and a survey sampling frame that reaches people without reliable internet access or proficiency in English. The Australian Immunisation Register can support aggregate comparisons, but it should not be treated as a substitute for community-defined participation or as a complete record outside its coverage settings.

Survey items can examine perceived safety, trust in clinicians and government, ease of booking, time away from work, preferred locations and exposure to inconsistent online claims. Weight results where appropriate, report uncertainty and missing responses, and compare patterns by place and service access rather than labelling whole neighbourhoods as hesitant. Pair each striking statistic with relevant qualitative accounts before recommending a response.

Protect trust, privacy and equity

Ethical safeguards are part of the method, not paperwork added later. Participation should be voluntary and without pressure from service staff; participants should know how findings will be used; and small-group discussions need extra care around confidentiality. Health information should be minimised, encrypted and destroyed according to an agreed schedule, especially when it could expose immigration status or family circumstances.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander data governance should follow agreements set by the relevant communities, not generic institutional templates. A logic model can clarify intended changes, responsible actions and evidence gaps before fieldwork begins. Teams can use the training centre's practice resource to prompt practical discussion about those decisions.

Translate evidence into service action

Integration is where mixed methods earn their value. Build a joint display that places survey findings beside interview quotations, focus-group themes and service data, then examine where they agree, conflict or illuminate one another. Disagreement is informative: high stated intention alongside missed appointments may point to access, while confidence can remain low even when a service is nearby.

Translate findings into practical pathways for Australia's mixed service market of general practices, community pharmacies, local councils, settlement services and Aboriginal community-controlled health organisations. Consider familiar channels such as walk-in pharmacy clinics, school sessions, council pop-ups and appointment reminders. Tailor the message, messenger and location for each community instead of running one national message through every channel.

Start a practical evidence-to-action cycle

Public health teams can begin with a focused question, a compensated community advisory group and one measurable service outcome. The training centre's courses in mixed-methods research, qualitative methods and focus-group facilitation, together with student field-placement opportunities, can help staff build skills while learning with community partners rather than extracting data from them.

Start by selecting one coverage gap, naming the partners who must shape the response and agreeing how results will be reviewed and shared. Use the evidence to improve booking support, referral pathways, staffing and communication, then publish a plain-language summary with community feedback on what was heard and what changed. Make the next cycle accountable to the people whose trust made the inquiry possible.

Introduction to Qualitative Research

Learners will explore the most common approaches to and data collection methods in qualitative research.

Is NYNJ:

Introduction to Mixed Methods Research

The following course is designed to provide the learner with an introduction to the benefits of mixed methods, different mixed methods research designs, and methods of analyzing and integrating mixed methods data.

Is NYNJ:

Facilitating Focus Groups

Focus groups are commonly used in the field of public health and are especially appropriate in pursuing “how” and “why” questions. Learn how to plan and moderate a focus group using specific skills, strategies, and techniques.

Is NYNJ:

Advanced Program Evaluation

Learn how to complete the advanced program evaluation tasks. Using the CDC Program Evaluation Framework, learners will connect each step of the framework with a section of the evaluation plan.

Is NYNJ:

Pages